Chapter VI: The Ideal.
§ 110.
The title of this chapter is ambiguous. When we call a state of
things ideal
we may mean three distinct things, which have only this in
common: that we always do mean to assert, of the state of things in question,
not only that it is good in itself, but that it is good in itself in a much
higher degree than many other things. The first of these meanings of
ideal
is (1) that to which the phrase The Ideal
is most
properly confined. By this is meant the best state of things
conceivable, the Summum Bonum or Absolute
Good. It is in this sense that a right conception of Heaven would be a right
conception of the Ideal: we mean by the Ideal a state of things which would be
absolutely perfect. But this conception may be quite clearly distinguished from
a second, namely, (2) that of the best possible state of things in this
world. This second conception may be identified with that which has frequently
figured in philosophy as the Human Good,
or the ultimate end
towards which our action should be directed. It is in this sense that Utopias
are said to be Ideals. the constructor of an Utopia may suppose many things to
be possible, which are in fact impossible; but he always assumes that some
things, at least, are rendered impossible by natural laws, and hence his
construction differs essentially from one which may disregard all
natural laws, however certainly established. At all events the question What
is the best state of things which we could possibly bring about?
is
quite distinct from the question What would be the best state of things
conceivable?
But, thirdly, we may mean by calling a state of things
ideal
merely (3) that it is good in itself in a high degree. And it is
obvious that the question what things are ideal
in this sense is one
which must be answered before we can pretend to settle what is the Absolute or
the Human Good. It is with the Ideal, in this third sense, that this chapter
will be principally concerned. Its main object is to arrive at some positive
answer to the fundamental question of Ethics—the question: What things
are goods or ends in themselves?
To this question we have hitherto obtained
only a negative answer: the answer that pleasure is certainly not the sole
good. (§ 110 ¶ 1)